High-Stakes Medicine: How Malpractice Lawsuits in Sports are Shaping the Orthopedic Industry
Imagine being the orthopedic surgeon tasked with a star athlete’s care—thousands (even millions!) of fans watching, a contract worth tens of millions on the line, and every decision scrutinized under a legal microscope. One misstep – or perceived misstep – can spark a lawsuit with staggering damages.
From NFL legends to high school athletes, the stakes in sports medicine have skyrocketed, fueled by escalating player contracts and the rise of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals. This intersection of sports, law, and medical care demands attention, as recent high-profile lawsuits highlight how orthopedic practices must adapt to keep pace.
This article explores how recent malpractice lawsuits are reshaping the orthopedic industry, offering insights on legal trends, risk management strategies, and the implications for physicians.
The Legal Landscape
Professional sports and malpractice lawsuits have crossed paths in ways that demand attention. Recent legal precedents highlight an escalating trend of high-stakes claims, many involving career-ending injuries or long-term disabilities. The white paper, “A Fresh Look at Professional Liability in Orthopedics” authored by AOP’s President and Chief Medical Officer Dr. Ted Schlegel, outlines some of the most significant cases that have set this tone.
Consider Chris Maragos, a former NFL safety awarded $43.5 million in damages in 2023 following a knee injury that ended his career. Or Michael Cox, a former New York Giants running back, who won $28.5 million in 2022 over a failed ankle surgery. These cases exemplify the tremendous liabilities professionals face, with the size of awarded judgments disrupting the malpractice insurance market.
Athletes’ futures can carry massive financial implications, particularly as high school and college players secure lucrative NIL contracts.
Legal scrutiny is intensifying, and players of all levels—professional, collegiate, and even high school—bring unique risks, especially as their compensation grows.
Risk Management Strategies for Orthopedic Professionals
High-profile cases may grab headlines, but they also bring a wake-up call to orthopedic practitioners about improving risk management strategies. While perfection isn’t always possible, mitigating lawsuits stems from being proactive.
Practical Approaches
- Thorough Documentation: Detailed clinical records remain the most essential tool in proving sound decision-making. Ensure all examinations, decisions, and consultations are accurate and complete.
- Enhanced Patient-Consent Practices: Full transparency with athletes (and their families, when relevant) is key. Conversations about the risks, benefits, and alternatives of any procedure should be clear and well-documented in writing.
- Second Opinions and Team Collaboration: Multidisciplinary collaboration is invaluable, particularly for high-profile or high-pressure cases. Internal reviews can provide an added layer of assurance in contentious situations.
- Liability Insurance Updates: Given skyrocketing malpractice insurance premiums, practices must regularly review coverage options. AOP’s partnership with Gallagher, a leading provider of innovative PLI solutions, serves as an example of how to control costs while maintaining robust protection.
- Ongoing Medical and Legal Education: Given the rapid evolution of malpractice trends, staying informed is crucial. Continued education on legal standards and emerging cases can help practitioners stay ahead of liabilities.
By adopting these strategies, orthopedic professionals can safeguard their practices, patients, and reputations while focusing on delivering care.
Broader Implications for the Orthopedic Industry
The surge in malpractice lawsuits impacts more than just individual cases—it affects the orthopedic industry as a whole.
Costs and Accessibility of Care
The financial strain from expensive lawsuits and rising insurance premiums could force some practices to limit the patients they treat or reconsider covering athletes altogether. This mirrors concerns raised by the American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine (AOSSM), which warned of a looming crisis if physicians opt out of treating high-risk athletes.
Changes in Medical Practices
Practitioners may become more conservative in their treatment, fearing litigation even for decisions that follow professional standards. This could result in delayed treatment, increased pressure to refer cases out, and hindered innovation in athlete-focused care. However, with every challenge comes opportunity. Practices that adapt and integrate thorough risk management programs stand to set themselves apart, emerging as leaders in an increasingly competitive market.
The Patient-Centered Approach
Addressing malpractice risks starts and ends with the patient—both their care and their understanding of procedures. Orthopedic professionals who prioritize transparency, shared decision-making, and open communication are far less likely to encounter lawsuits.
Education and Support
Athletes rely on their medical teams to shepherd them through high-stakes recovery periods. Detailed explanations about injury prognoses, post-operative care, and return-to-play guidelines are non-negotiable. For every malpractice horror story, there are success stories where patient-first care led to expedited recovery and prolonged careers.
Integration with Value-Based Care
The broader healthcare industry’s shift toward value-based care—focusing on measurable patient outcomes—aligns seamlessly with efforts to reduce malpractice claims. When care is focused squarely on improving outcomes and reducing risks, litigation risks naturally follow suit.
Rising to the Challenge of High-Stakes Care
The dual pressures of delivering exceptional care while navigating sky-high legal risks can feel daunting. But for orthopedic professionals, these challenges also present opportunities to innovate and lead. By focusing on patient-first practices, leveraging robust legal protections, and staying proactive in education and risk management, practitioners can strengthen their resilience in a field that demands both precision and adaptability.
No Comments